By Erno Marius Obogeanu-Hempel
The most well-known saying goes: “When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.” In German: “As soon as a metric becomes a goal in itself, it loses its significance.”
The author of this law is Charles A. E. Goodhart (born 1936), a British economist, former advisor to the Bank of England, and professor at the London School of Economics.
The idea behind this is simple: Key performance indicators (KPIs) are originally intended to measure success. However, when they become an end in themselves, people’s behavior often changes—and with it, the KPI’s relevance.
A key performance indicator (KPI) is, first and foremost, an indicator of something valuable. However, as soon as people are rewarded or punished for optimizing that metric, they begin to focus on optimizing the metric itself rather than the actual goal. As a result, the metric loses its meaning. Our article ” OKR vs. KPI” explains how KPIs and OKRs differ.
Examples
Goodhart’s Law explains why Objectives and Key Results serve different purposes:
The Objective describes the desired end state and the intended benefit. The key results are measurable indicators of whether we are moving closer to the target state or have achieved it by the end of the cycle. They are proxies for the desired outcome—not the outcome itself. That’s why you should regularly ask yourself:
Are we really optimizing the desired outcome—or just the metrics?
Goodhart’s Law doesn’t call for less measurement—but for smarter measurement. That’s exactly what OKR is.
Traditional goal-setting often involves stating, “Increase the number of leads.” Then, that specific metric is maximized.
In the case of OKR, this could be, for example:
Objective
We have consistently attracted more qualified new customers to ensure our profitable growth over the long term.
Key Results
This creates a tension:
It is only the interplay of several key results that defines the desired success. They represent different facets of the outcome and prevent a single metric from becoming the sole target for optimization.
Customer Support
Objective: We have enabled our customers to experience the best support in the industry.
A single key result such as “Reduced average call duration from 6 to less than 4 minutes” would obviously be problematic.
Because the question immediately arises: How does this contribute to the objective?
A well-balanced set of key results might look like this instead:
It is only the interplay of these key results that defines excellent support. No single metric could achieve this on its own. The objective serves as a plausibility filter: Each key result must clearly contribute to the desired target state.
Perhaps the most important difference, however, lies in its consistent focus on outcomes.
Many KPIs measure activities. Examples:
Instead, OKR asks: What impact do we want to achieve?
For example, don’t: ❌ Develop 20 features
but ✅:
So you’re not optimizing the work itself, but rather its impact.
Success isn’t defined by a single metric—but rather by the interplay of several key results.
That is precisely why a good OKR does not consist of as many metrics as possible, but rather of a few Key Results that complement each other effectively.
In OKR as well, Key Results remain metrics. That is why Goodhart’s Law generally applies within an OKR system as well.
The key difference, however, is that OKR systematically reduces these negative effects:
Goodhart’s Law therefore does not refute OKR. On the contrary, it provides a compelling rationale for why modern goal-setting systems like OKR require multiple outcome-oriented key results rather than a single metric.
You are currently viewing a placeholder content from Facebook. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More InformationYou are currently viewing a placeholder content from Instagram. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More InformationYou are currently viewing a placeholder content from X. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More Information